Caral Civilization Peru: Haas/Creamer 2001 Disculpa/Apology

« Reply of Dr. Shady to PANC (Proyecto Arqueológico Norte Chico) (English version) | Main | New Moseley Article on Maritime Foundations »

January 24, 2005

Haas/Creamer 2001 Disculpa/Apology

Jonathan Haas mandó este mensaje por correo electrónico el 21 de Mayo de 2001 a una larga lista de destinarios, pidiendo disculpa por el malentendido ocasionado es ese entonces por sus entrevistas con la prensa después de la publicación del artículo de Shady, Haas y Creamer in Science.

Jonathan Haas sent this email message on 21 May 2001 to a long list of recipients, apologizing for the misunderstandings that arose at that time from his interviews with the press following the publication of the Shady, Haas and Creamer article in Science.

Monday, May 21, 2001 11:11:19 AM
Message From: [email protected]
Subject: Setting the record straight

Dear Colleagues:

We are writing a note to everyone we can think of to try and set the record straight about the recent media frenzy surrounding the dating of the site of Caral in the Supe Valley. We specifically want to accord full credit for the excavations and research at Caral to Dr. Ruth Shady and her tremendous team of students at the Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos. Many of the news stories painted me and my wife/colleague, Winifred Creamer as the leaders in this project, and this is simply not the case. Dr. Shady is the project leader and principle investigator and we have recently joined her in a collaborative effort to more fully explore the Preceramic occupation of the Supe Valley and eventually that whole stretch of the central Peruvian Coast. Our role in the dating of Caral was to help take a series of Radiocarbon samples out of well-provenienced contexts already excavated by Dr. Shady, and then we brought those samples up the U.S. and had them analyzed.

It is with deepest regret that much of the media coverage did not give Dr. Shady and her students appropriate attention in the news reports and we publically apologize for the role we may have played in this misapprehension. For those of you who want to read a balanced and accurate news account of the project, I refer you to the May 7, 2001 edition of Newsweek (link).

Jonathan Haas

January 24, 2005 | Permalink

Comments

hogan stivaletto
HOGAN USATE
sito hogan
hogan online outlet
Hogan Firenze
The Mall Hogan
punti vendita hogan
hogan sandali
hogan prezzo
HOGAN CALZATURE
hogan scarpe bambino
costo hogan
OUTLET HOGAN ROMA
hogan outlet serravalle
HOGAN BAMBINA
hogan giglio
hogan 35
HOGAN ABBIGLIAMENTO
HOGAN CON ZEPPA
nuove hogan
spaccio hogan milano

Posted by: spaccio hogan milano | August 13, 2013 at 09:34 AM

mulberry clutch
MULBERRY BAGS HANDBAGS
mulberry designer bag uk
Mulberry Leather Satchel
Mulberry Bags For Girls
mulberry bag willow
mulberry outlets online
sale mulberry handbags
mulberry men
cheap mulberry purses
mulberry handbags uk
replica mulberry bags
MULBERRY FASHION STORE
Cheap Mulberry Fashion
mulberry bag crossover
mulberry coach bags
MULBERRY BAG ALEXA
mulberry small purses
Mulberry Travel Bags
Mulberry Outlet Online
mulberry bag shop uk
mulberry outlet york uk
Mulberry Bag Online Uk
buy mulberry bags
mulberry bag shop online
mulberry mini flower bag box
Mulberry Leather Bag Uk
MULBERRY UK SALE
MESSENGER MULBERRY BAG
mulberry handbag outlet
mulberry for men
mulberry bags new york
Mulberry Daria
mulberry luggage
mulberry mini flower bag
mulberry bag for sale
mulberry outlet store
Mulberry Clutch Bag
mulberry bag duty free price
mulberry purses wallets

Posted by: mulberry purses wallets | August 13, 2013 at 09:22 AM

tuta gucci
Costume Gucci Uomo
Zaino Gucci
gucci borse uomo
catalogo borse gucci
borse gucci bauletto
trolley gucci
ABBIGLIAMENTO GUCCI
outlet gucci online
Ballerine Gucci
GUCCI OROLOGI
gucci lugano
OUTLET BORSE GUCCI
gucci verona
portamonete gucci
borse gucci originali
GUCCI BORSE
Simbolo Gucci
sneakers gucci uomo
the mall gucci
Scarpe Gucci Donna
portafoglio gucci uomo
Jackie O Gucci
Gucci Scarpe Uomo
Bauletti Gucci
GUCCI TORINO
Borse Gucci 2011
GUCCI NEGOZI
scarpe gucci online
Gucci Bimbo
cintura gucci prezzo
Borse Gucci Uomo
gucci sito
GUCCI SALDI
gucci vestiti
PORTAFOGLI GUCCI
Spaccio Gucci Firenze
Portafogli Gucci Donna

Posted by: Portafogli Gucci Donna | August 13, 2013 at 09:10 AM

saldi gucci
GUCCI OUTLET FIRENZE
borse gucci
scarpe gucci online
decolte gucci
abbigliamento gucci
bauletto gucci prezzo
Sfilata Gucci
Borse Gucci Prezzo
gucci bimbo
fermasoldi gucci
BORSETTE GUCCI
GUCCI OCCHIALI
costumi gucci
Immagini Borse Gucci
SANDALI GUCCI
foulard gucci
SIMBOLO GUCCI
abiti gucci
STILISTA GUCCI
Gucci Uomo
outlet gucci italia
SHOPPING BAG GUCCI
collezione gucci borse
BORSE GUCCI BAULETTO
PORTAMONETE GUCCI
Cintura Uomo Gucci
Gucci Cinture Uomo
JEANS GUCCI
Borse Gucci Prezzi
Scarpe Gucci Uomo
Spaccio Gucci

Posted by: Spaccio Gucci | August 13, 2013 at 09:08 AM

gucci shoes sale
gucci mens shoes
Gucci Hat
cheap gucci handbags
Gucci Official Site
authentic gucci outlet
gucci hobo
GUCCI ONLINE OUTLET
GUCCI OUTLET STORE ONLINE
Gucci Men Shoes
Gucci Watch
gucci usa
gucci bags outlet
GUCCI WOMENS SHOES
gucci shoes men
gucci bags sale
Gucci Outlet San Marcos
AUTHENTIC GUCCI HANDBAGS
Gucci By Gucci
cheap gucci
gucci backpack
gucci shoes on sale
GUCCI BELT BAG
Gucci Eyeglasses
GUCCI HOBO BAG
GUCCI SHOES WOMEN
CHEAP GUCCI BELTS
gucci shoes for women
mens gucci sneakers
GUCCI SHOE
gucci outlet locations

Posted by: gucci outlet locations | August 13, 2013 at 09:08 AM

LOUIS VUITTON BAG SPEEDY
original louis vuitton
Louis Vuitton Case Iphone
louis vuitton sneakers for women
louis vuitton gm
louis vuitton belt
louis vuitton tote
cheap louis vuitton purses
buy cheap louis vuitton bags online
louis vuitton pocket organizer
louis vuitton brown
louis vuitton sac occasion
Cheap Louis Vuitton Wallets For Women
designer bags louis vuitton
louis vuitton monogram belt
LOUIS VUITTON UK SALE
louis vuitton suitcase price
louis vuitton backpack uk
louis vuitton second hand
Louis Vuitton Belts For Sale
louis vuitton travel case
Louis Vuitton In India
louis vuitton charms replica
discount louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton belt mens
Louis Vuitton Mens Jackets
Louis Vuitton Sneakers For Kids
brand new louis vuitton
louis vuitton zippy wallet m60017
knock-off louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton tote monogram
louis vuitton card holder
FAKE LOUIS VUITTON SUNGLASSES
Most Popular Louis Vuitton Shoes
fake louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton boots
Louis Vuitton Paris Bags
CHEAP LOUIS VUITTON BELTS UK
Louis Vuitton Messenger
replica louis vuitton
SHOP FOR LOUIS VUITTON HANDBAGS
Louis Vuitton Hat
louis vuitton mens wallet
louis vuitton keepall 55
louis vuitton wallets
louis vuitton ipod case
LOUIS VUITTON WARDROBE
LOUIS VUITTON AUTHENTIC

Posted by: LOUIS VUITTON AUTHENTIC | August 13, 2013 at 09:08 AM

dmqxcnau
[url=http://www.g0656m9ed5v7021nbu75w276l0cjutvis.com/]dmqxcnau[/url]
dmqxcnau http://www.g0656m9ed5v7021nbu75w276l0cjutvis.com/

Posted by: dmqxcnau | August 13, 2013 at 08:48 AM

nnaubrbh
[url=http://www.g02m24tb7wl57c8ivz16akl4u6z004x4s.com/]nnaubrbh[/url]
nnaubrbh http://www.g02m24tb7wl57c8ivz16akl4u6z004x4s.com/

Posted by: nnaubrbh | August 13, 2013 at 08:43 AM

http://www.menssunglasses2012.com,tiffany outlet,ray ban sunglasses,Cheap Ray Bans,http://www.ekorosk.com,Ray Ban,ray ban uk,ray ban uk,ray ban outlet ,cheap ray bans/,ray ban uk,ray ban,ray ban sunglasses/,ray ban wayfarer,http://www.edesignersunglassesuk.com ,ray ban uk,ray ban uk,Cheap Ray Ban Wayfarer,Cheap Oakley Sunglasses,Cheap Oakley Sunglasses,ray ban uk,Carrera Sunglasses,tiffany outlet,karen millen outlet,Fake Ray Bans ,ray ban outlet,fake oakleys,karen millen outlet,ray ban outlet,ray ban aviators,fake ray bans uk,fake ray bans,ray ban outlet,http://www.h2-nrg.co.uk/rayban.php,ray ban uk,karen millen,http://www.menssunglasses2012.com,ray ban uk,tiffany outlet/,cheap supra shoes/ ,Fake Ray Bans UK,ray ban uk,Ray Ban UK,http://www.bleubury.com,http://localschoolsnetwork.org.uk/fakeraybansuk.php,http://localschoolsnetwork.org.uk/cheapraybans.php,http://localschoolsnetwork.org.uk/replicaraybans.php,http://www.parkside-school.co.uk/raybans.php,http://www.parkside-school.co.uk/wayfarer.php,http://www.parkside-school.co.uk/rayban.php,http://www.equalfutures.org.uk/fakeraybans.php,http://www.equalfutures.org.uk/replicaraybans.php,http://www.equalfutures.org.uk/raybanwayfarer.php,http://www.aidan.co.uk/raybans.php,http://www.aidan.co.uk/raybanmall.php,http://www.aidan.co.uk/rayban.php,http://www.artisanwebsites.co.uk/clubmaster.php,http://www.artisanwebsites.co.uk/shop.php,http://www.artisanwebsites.co.uk/raybansale.php,http://www.treviglas.net/replicaraybans.php,http://www.treviglas.net/rayban.php,http://www.treviglas.net/cheapraybansuk.php,http://www.adobemagic.com/cheap-ray-bans-sunglasses.php,http://www.adobemagic.com/fakeraybans.php,http://www.adobemagic.com/ray-bans-wayfarer.php,http://www.adobemagic.com/ray-bans.php,http://myhomelife.org.uk/Ray-Ban-Jackie-Ohh.php,http://www.myhomelife.org.uk/Ray-Ban-Cats.php,http://www.myhomelife.org.uk/Ray-Ban-Aviator.php,http://www.myhomelife.org.uk/Ray-Ban-Clubmaster.php,

Posted by: ray ban uk | August 13, 2013 at 08:34 AM

OSBFCv yuswmrtxybza, [url=http://ltbnwcbsqjld.com/]ltbnwcbsqjld[/url], [link=http://fegdgwtvfwuc.com/]fegdgwtvfwuc[/link], http://iafrqtnvnqzo.com/

Posted by: qjogphwejyh | August 07, 2013 at 10:05 AM

Add‘longer use up your time and efforts within a wow/lady,so , who isn‘capital t prepared waste matter their energy for you.

Posted by: grosasara | August 04, 2013 at 12:04 AM

The following ones are sometimes reported: blurred vision, diarrhea, loss of appetite, seizures, trouble concentrating, muscle twitching, and tingling; http://seekmeds.co.uk/ viagra , make sure you talk to your health care provider before starting the treatment.

Posted by: http://seekmeds.co.uk/ | July 22, 2013 at 03:17 AM

Adipex (phentermine) is an anti-obesity agent used for the treatment of obesity in patients that need additional help fighting their food cravings: http://1unitedkingdom-pills-uk.co.uk/ cheap propecia , it's widely used to treat obesity and help people suffering from it to go back to normal eating patterns.

Posted by: propecia without a prescription | July 21, 2013 at 01:40 AM

Ysc7DB sfuqjjgjbxii, [url=http://dqpfqqsiqjtl.com/]dqpfqqsiqjtl[/url], [link=http://xrjzgyjtswpf.com/]xrjzgyjtswpf[/link], http://vptqhtbeuvss.com/

Posted by: ofrnlguzyv | July 06, 2013 at 07:30 AM

[B - [URL=http://www.uchristianlouboutin-australia.net/ - Christian Louboutin Shoes[/URL - [/B - ow that the foot type can be figured out, a running shoe is usually chosen. shoe that can absorb amaze is needed by those with high arches. his will help all of the foot to pronate a little more. aving an ideal fit is critical for modified comfort. f your feet you should not fit properly into the black-jack shoe then you will have problems, as your base size changes throughout the your life. nd f you are having lower limb problems, etrex shoes are a good choice as they offer great comfort. eceive information that will impact your life not to mention assist you in receiving the promises associated with od such as health, prosperity, and additionally healed and healthy human relationships. hristian article will give you training in using the full armor and waiting therefore. he belt of truth is put into place with the truths found in the ord.. here are numerous places that a consumer can turn to when they are shopping around for footwear. any popular department stores are going to have the whole footwear section, complete with support services specialists that can help. emember that the best deals can typically be found while shopping in the world wide web. he length of your personal heel lift depends on an individuals shoe size. n most cases you are going to get high heel lifts that created for your measurements, though not all hindfoot lifts are manufactured with the equivalent pattern. robably the most comfortable lifting contain a tapered physical appearance having an an elevated heel and extremely small arch.

ake them want to meet you in the interview. o highlight an individual's strengths and qualifications for the position they are hiring designed for. his will need to rewritten to address every person employer that you will be sending a canopy letter to.. ike it offers an embedded real money simulator which can make your real money session get. n case your technique will be based on different roulette substances groups like: numbers, creases, streets, corners, ... or even at all roulette elements and on more complex static or powerful progressions, then the best choice for sure is going to be oulette cripter tudio. lot of people try going down the physical product road as well as fail to quit smoking and whip themselves up about it telling things " am only just weak" or " just do not have sufficient willpower to stop". on't beat all by yourself up about your failure to stop smoking using these methods. l is not your fault you have got not succeeded, you have simply been going about quitting smoking the way. otton ropes make all of these purposes possible because of the feel not to mention texture but the strength furthermore they offer. f course, organic cotton rope can be used in a variety of other methods as well, just as every type associated with rope. o matter what start using, however, cotton rope is ready to supply a unique service..

[B - [URL=http://www.ghdbaratas-espana.net/ - comprar ghd[/URL - [/B - ell, let me tell you this... there are more alternatives to mole removal than you might have understood. e have some the specifics of surgery and laser skin removal therapy as options for mole removal, but like any other treatment options there can be unwanted outcomes to these methods. he most common shift in the best way people seem to get hired at the moment is through temporary to long-lasting positions. hile it can be frustrating to be effective in a temporary purgatory for several times, getting hired to a full time mum programming job with amazing benefits can be worth the investment. hese temp-to-perm positions are sometimes advertised by local staff agencies. ira hair petroleum comes with a natural herbal shampoo and conditioner. ou use this herbal product to wash your hair immediately after you may have applied the ira curly hair oil. lternatively it is possible to use whatever shampoo but you have to make specific you make use of an apple cider off with it-this apple cider rinse is created by taking one teaspoon for apple cider and mixing them with one liter normal water, use this to wash away synthetics from your hair. ow, it also section of the moniker for a isconsin iver tour on the pper ells glacial park. he .. 109 oat atrol sightseeing excursion is narrated, drawing on the two history and legend of the pond, and showcases the sandstone pebbles formations.

he earth station antenna look angle (azimuth & elevation) are usually calculated using the longitude of the geosynchronous satellite tv on pc plus the latitude and longitude of the planet station. he deviation of the planet station antenna pointing route from the antenna electric axis known as the antenna pointing mistakes. his error reduces the gain of the earth station antenna for the reason that antenna gain is max when measured at it has the electric axis. n addition to properties, concert, theatrical endeavors in addition to protecting ackson asset and copyrights, m ohme ohme and ichael ackson had many other projects in the works. ost essentially, in addition to overseeing ackson day to day home business matters, r. ohme spent considerable time working to renegotiate greater loan terms on ackson 50% share with the ony- usic ublishing atalog, a highly valued asset of which ackson had previously taken out considerable loans on to support his / her lifestyle.. ne thing always do before start to gap is make certain cut my nozzle correctly. testosterone levels is vital for a nice expert finish that you get this area right. hese nozzles have either a sealed end or little hole already in ending of the nozzle.

[B - [URL=http://www.cheap-drebeatsaustralia.net/ - Dr Dre Headphones[/URL - [/B - he amsung -3600 lu-ray layer is a perfect substitute for meet all your igh efinition needs. any kind of experts consider the -3600 to be one of the best lu-ray layers. -- rice you should consider when purchasing -- nder $300.00. t number 3, we have the ony peria . ony, since their very own parting of ways in making with ricsson, has developed some great looking and really powerful mobile handsets. he ony peria is undoubtedly one of the best. forklift is definitely an industrial vehicle with a hydraulically handled vertical mast and pallet forks. orklifts are a common sight in warehouses around the world and generally don't have the capability to deliver the results off hard surfaces except they are specifically built for my terrain capability. he pallet forks or perhaps tines are inserted under significant amounts to lift, stack and move them. hen learning, you need to keep a clean bathroom towel in your golf bag to help wipe the head of the organization. t home, you must start using a pointed object to pick about the individual groove to eliminate your dirt, mud, or yards that remained. ou ought to remember not to use whatever metal to pick on the lines as this can scratch that protective coating of your pub that protects it coming from rust.

Posted by: yxu994y4q | June 23, 2013 at 11:04 AM

Fantastic blog! Do you have any hints for aspiring writers? I'm planning to start my own site soon but I'm a little lost on everything. Would you suggest starting with a free platform like Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I'm totally overwhelmed .. Any tips? Appreciate it!

Posted by: breast actives reviews | May 02, 2013 at 07:18 PM

I'm very glad to join in caralperu.typepad.com, I post to this category this
http://waxdj.com/djs/26787/about.php -It's good to be someone who appreciate uniqueness and who is similar to you in some kind of way. Maybe it's about the person you want to be but it's desperate to try to be something that is opposite of your own nature. It should be someone that makes you feel good about being yourself, you should not compare with him wishing you were prettier. Emulate him, but put your own individuality into the things he does. http://www.bizsugar.com/user/profile/dvleguuro
What They SayThe discovery of extraordinary ruins beneath the high school becomes the adventure of a lifetime when several students and their teacher are transported to the magical world of El-Hazard! There, each learns to cope with strange new powers and even stranger surroundings. However, during this process, the audio for the first few episodes is slightly off-kilter, thus throwing off the timing on the subtitles horribly in places. The problem mostly rectifies itself by episode three. Whether listening to the original 2.0 or the new 5.1 track, the audio comes through very well. The 5.1 track sounds slightly clearer, and definitely allows you to feel immersed in the film. The audio on the English 2.0 track suffers slightly from the same problem that the original Japanese 2.0 track has, in that it sounds very slightly fuzzy. Regardless, it is still far superior to the audio previously available on the VHS releases. Animated by AIC, the lush backgrounds for the "magnificent world" are absolutely stunning, and there is virtually no graininess whatsoever on the backgrounds or the characters. Each character has a very high level of detail to them, from the emblems on their clothing to the detailing of shadowing and shimmering effects. Also, fans of other series such as Ergo Proxy, Samurai Champloo, and Heroic Legend of Arslan may recognize the beautiful work of character designer Nakazawa Kazuto. Packaging: The case for the disc features some very nice artwork, including a clear case with a picture on the reverse side of the cover. It is not intended to be a reversible cover, but merely to provide additional images of the main characters in the volume. There are images (some less intricate than others) for all of the menu screens, and music accompanies most of them. Each episode has its own screen, with several chapter stops from which to select. Extras: The only extra included on the disc is an art gallery, featuring over 50 images. Some are taken directly as screen captures from the series itself, although the majority of them are not. There are many which are taken from the animation books, showing close-ups of character features and line-art (which is, unfortunately, cut off in many of the pictures). Also included are several pictures taken from art books, depicting some beautiful watercolors. However, I would highly advise that you NOT view the image gallery until after you have watched both volumes of the series, as some of the images (especially those toward the end) show spoilers from the second volume. Almost immediately upon arriving, Makoto and Fujisawa-sensei save Rune Venus, one of the two princesses of Roshtaria, from the Bugrom, giant bug-like creatures who possess amazing physical strength. Astonished by the incredible strength Fujisawa-sensei has suddenly gained (which he used to defeat the Bugrom), there is little time to ponder over this as they find themselves rushed to the palace. Seeing Makoto as his life-long rival, Jinnai is especially determined to overcome the Alliance and be the ruler of El-Hazard once he realizes that Makoto is working to unseal an ancient weapon. He launches a series of successful invasions of border countries, and ultimately declares that he must also have access to a weapon of unequaled power in order to utterly crush Makoto once and for all. There, they hope to gain audience with the three priestesses who still worship the ancient gods, and break the seal on the Eye of God, which is said to have destroyed El-Hazard in ancient times. The priestesses are reluctant to do this, until they learn that the Bugrom Queen Diva intends to resurrect the ancient demon god Ifurita, the most taboo thing in all of El-Hazard. Nanami meets up with Makoto and Fujisawa-sensei as they are consulting the priestesses at a hot spring, and immediately joins them in their endeavors (after all, prior to this, she has been working as a waitress and a lunch-box saleswoman). During all of this, a secret organization the Phantom Tribe working in the underground caves of El-Hazard plot to assassinate Makoto as part of their plans to conquer El-Hazard for themselves!When Jinnai plan reach the forbidden island succeeds, Makoto is shocked to recognize the ancient demon god as the same beautiful girl who sent him (and his colleagues) to El-Hazard in the first place. Unfortunately, she has no memory of this event ever taking place, and begins to launch an attack on the Alliance under the command of Jinnai and the Bugrom!With three powerful groups vying for control of the world, the disc wraps up at a point which perfectly sets the stage for the final battles that will take place in volume 2. 锘縀legant Restaurants in North ConwayFinancial Advice: Why Paying For it Saves You Money http://choowawa.com/user.php?login=svsllzurd

Posted by: Owneneunreany | May 20, 2012 at 12:39 PM

Hello Charlotte,

I believe all the dates obtained so far are associated with the platform mounds and domestic architecture. I don't recall the exact number but there are between 120 and 140 carbon dates now for the Fortaleza, Partivilca, Supe, and Huaura River Valley sites, so listing them here would not be easy. If you would like to email me ([email protected]) I would be happy to supply you with more information.

Also, let me suggest that if you are interested in learning more about Caral and the other Supe Valley sites that you purchase Dr. Shady's book: Caral, The City of the Sacred Fire. Which is available in a combination Spanish/English version. I received my copy about a week ago and I consider it invaluable. You can go to my site at this url to find the ordering information:

http://www.hallofmaat.com/read.php?1,333109,333109#msg-333109

Kat Reece

Posted by: Katherine Reece | March 28, 2005 at 02:08 PM